Home > Case Studies > I Felt Sad Even Though Separation Was My Choice: Case Study

I Felt Sad Even Though Separation Was My Choice: Case Study

By: Maggie Lonsdale BA (hons) - Updated: 19 Sep 2012 | comments*Discuss
Couple Change Separation Friends Family

Separation is difficult for everybody involved, even if you’re the person that has instigated the split. Although it may be more difficult to gain sympathy if you are seen as the ‘bad guy’, it doesn’t mean that you don’t have your own emotional issues to come to term with.

For Julie Pringle, 39, for Cambridge, the end of her marriage to her childhood sweetheart shocked her friends and family. Having been married for fifteen years and together for twenty, Julie and her husband Dave had two young children.

Julie told us how the split came about and the problems she faced with mutual friends blaming her for the break up. She said, “My husband and I had not really been getting on for a while – we never had major arguments but I just had this nagging feeling that I hadn’t really experienced life. We’d got together so young, while we were still in the sixth form, and I felt as though there were things I wanted to do with my life that Dave really wasn’t interested in. For a couple of years before we split up I tried to see if there was a way of incorporating my dreams into our life together, by suggesting we go on a scuba diving holiday or spend time learning a new hobby, but Dave seemed more content with life as it was.”

Only One Person Wanted Change

Eventually, this difference of opinion in how their daily life should be drove them apart. Julie wanted to experience life outside their home town but Dave didn’t. She continued, “It’s the classic itchy feet issue I suppose. I loved being a wife and a mum to our two daughters but it wasn’t enough for me, as bad as that sounds. I didn’t want to just be mum – I know I’m a good mum and I am more than proud of how wonderfully polite and interesting my daughters are – but I’m a firm believer that daughters need a strong role model in their mum, rather than just seeing someone who cooks and cleans.”

After signing up to take part in a sponsored charity cycle ride in the Brecon Beacons, Julie started to get involved with a new group of friends. She would train three times a week, taking her daughters on a long bike ride at weekends too to help increase her fitness. Julie said, “I felt myself really come alive. I was part of a group of women who were all keen to do something more, to help people and help themselves at the same time. I knew that I didn’t want to just spend my evenings watching telly; I wanted to take classes and travel and broaden my mind.”

Making a Difficult Choice

She continued, “I told Dave how I felt and said that I hoped he would support me and that we could do stuff together – I made it clear that I didn’t want to lose him – but he wasn’t interested and couldn’t understand why I was rocking the boat. I knew then that nothing would change and I could either leave and deal with the consequences or stay in this unfulfilled situation for ever. I chose to leave, which was one of the hardest things I’ve ever done.”

Although Julie planned to leave the family home and set herself up in a small rented flat in the same town, Dave decided it would be better for the girls if he moved out instead. Family and friends felt as though Julie was being very selfish, especially it was Dave that moved out, so she found herself being blanked in the town.

Julie said, “It took a long time for people to be friendly again. My parents were more supportive of course, but they too felt that I should have just got on with it. Dave’s parents were very cross with me and still won’t say hello if I see them in town. I know I wouldn’t get any sympathy, but they don’t understand that it’s been really hard for me too. I do love Dave and I thought we’d be together for ever, but I see it as he wasn’t prepared to let me flourish, so I had to leave.”

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Traceya
    Re: Selling the Jointly Owned Home
    Hi my husband and I are going through a divorce, ( the petition has been sent to the courts) I want the home put up for sale so…
    30 March 2020
  • Bblively50
    Re: Selling the Jointly Owned Home
    So wife and I got divorce but still own home in both our names. She does not want to sale and I do, She just wants to…
    10 March 2020
  • Harry
    Re: Selling the Jointly Owned Home
    Hi we both on title deeds but was origannly my wife's mother's house.. I have put in a lot of money to renovate it and now we…
    3 March 2020
  • Wads
    Re: Selling the Jointly Owned Home
    I just bought a house with my fiancé she lied and got me arrest to get me out the house and keep it , I will like her to buy me…
    3 March 2020
  • A.A.Sonawane
    Re: Selling the Jointly Owned Home
    in joint owner property one can release without permission of other
    28 February 2020
  • GrandDad
    Re: Selling the Jointly Owned Home
    My wife and I have been separated for 3 years most recently. Over 3 years previously and lived in different cities for 7 years.…
    11 February 2020
  • PaigeW
    Re: Selling the Jointly Owned Home
    Hi, my ex partner is still living in the house we both own and are both named on the mortgage. I moved out over a year ago and…
    6 February 2020
  • Terri
    Re: Selling the Jointly Owned Home
    My ex partner ( not married ) left the property at the weekend . We have a joint mortgage which I paid £600 into and he the…
    29 January 2020
  • MeMe
    Re: Selling the Jointly Owned Home
    My husband and I sold our home at the insistent of my son and daughter-in-law we are retired they assured us we would always…
    27 January 2020
  • Mel
    Re: Selling the Jointly Owned Home
    Hi just curious I have been in defector relationship for 9years. Relationship is strained after 19year old daughter moved in.we…
    21 January 2020